The role of organizational learning in soft regulation of workplace gender equality

Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to explain progress, or the lack of it, in achieving workplace gender equality goals prescribed by affirmative action regulation by using concepts from soft regulation and organizational learning.

Design/methodology/approach

The research design is a longitudinal study (2002-2012) of a critical case, that of a single large organization in the male-dominated steel manufacturing, distribution and mining industries. The case focusses on the evidence about organizational learning to be found in that organization’s reports to government on its activities to promote workplace gender equality.

Findings

While other factors play a role, the apparent failure of the soft regulation to generate a significant shift in gender equality outcomes may also be attributed to ineffective organizational learning, demonstrated by the absence of systematic reflection within the organization on how to improve workplace gender equality, and the lack of firm targets and external benchmarking.

Research limitations/implications

Self-reported data may be overstated or incomplete. More research is needed to confirm the nature of the specific learning processes occurring within organizations.

Practical implications

Absent the advent of hard sanctions in workplace gender equality regulation, the responsible government agencies may find it valuable to focus on ways to encourage target organizations to develop competence in organizational learning.

Social implications

More effective gender equality regulation may change organizational policy and practice and improve work opportunities for women.

Originality/value

Rather than concluding that the only alternative, when soft regulation is unsuccessful, is hard regulation, this paper shifts the focus to ways that soft regulatory processes might be improved to strengthen their effect.

Citation

Macneil, J. and Liu, Z. (2017), "The role of organizational learning in soft regulation of workplace gender equality", Employee Relations, Vol. 39 No. 3, pp. 317-334. https://doi.org/10.1108/ER-01-2016-0022