A new approach to journal ranking: social structure in hospitality and tourism journals

Abstract

Purpose

This study introduces a new approach, called the social structure approach, for ranking academic journals by focusing on hospitality and tourism journals; and a hybrid metric, including the combination of the journal impact factor via citations and a social network metric, called the journal knowledge domain index (JKDI).

Design/methodology/approach

Twenty-five hospitality and tourism journals were selected to test this approach. Collaboration-based metrics, productivity-based metrics, and network-based metrics are considered components of the social structure approach. Additionally, a hybrid metric, including the combination of the journal impact factor via citations and a social network metric, JKDI, is developed.

Findings

The study’s findings show that top or leading journals have a weaker position in some social structure approach metrics compared to other (or follower) journals. However, according to the JKDI, leading journals have remained constant with the other ranking studies.

Practical implications

The ranking of academic journals is vital for the stakeholders of academia. Consequently, the findings of this study may help stakeholders to design an optimal ranking system and formulate and implement effective research strategies for knowledge creation and dissemination.

Originality/value

As one of the first in the journal-ranking literature, this study has significant implications, as it introduces a new ranking approach.

Citation

Koseoglu, M.A. (2020), "A new approach to journal ranking: social structure in hospitality and tourism journals", International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, Vol. 32 No. 2, pp. 389-424. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJCHM-10-2017-0622