Critical social science as a research methodology in universities in times of crisis

Abstract

Purpose

To consider what a criticalist qualitative research methodology might look like for universities in the context of the contemporary COVID-19 crisis.

Design/methodology/approach

This polemical paper explores the rationale for a dramatic recasting of the approach needed in qualitative research methodology to address the challenges of the crisis-ridden times we live in. Broadly conceived of as an “evolving criticality”, to borrow from Kincheloe, the paper addresses the kind of disposition, orientation or state of mind required that provides the space and opportunities in universities within which this strategic methodological reinvention might occur. After explaining what a research methodology committed to the notion of “criticality” might look like, the paper argues that to enact this we need to start with the immediacy of our own academic work and then emanate to other public spheres.

Findings

The polemical exchange engaged in by this paper presents the underpinnings of how critical social science might be deployed in both reconceiving how we understand the purpose of research in universities and changing the nature of academic work.

Research limitations/implications

These exist only in so far as university academics are prepared to embrace what is being argued for to change the status quo.

Practical implications

The broader critical social science methodology being argued for in this paper is using a wider framing to a form of critical ethnography that has the potential to enable academic workers to extricate themselves from the ruinous situation brought on by the neoliberal paradigm that has been so drastically exacerbated by COVID-19.

Originality/value

While the paper rehearses some existing ideas of critical social science, the novelty of the papers lies in the way these are applied to the COVID-19 crisis within which universities have become embroiled.

Citation

Smyth, J. (2020), "Critical social science as a research methodology in universities in times of crisis", Qualitative Research Journal, Vol. 20 No. 4, pp. 351-360. https://doi.org/10.1108/QRJ-05-2020-0044