Prelims

Lisa M. Given (RMIT University, Australia)
Donald O. Case (University of Kentucky, USA)
Rebekah Willson (McGill University, Canada)

Looking for Information

ISBN: 978-1-80382-424-6, eISBN: 978-1-80382-423-9

ISSN: 2055-5377

Publication date: 30 June 2023

Citation

Given, L.M., Case, D.O. and Willson, R. (2023), "Prelims", Looking for Information (Studies in Information, Vol. 15), Emerald Publishing Limited, Leeds, pp. i-xx. https://doi.org/10.1108/S2055-53772023009

Publisher

:

Emerald Publishing Limited

Copyright © 2023 Lisa M. Given, Donald O. Case and Rebekah Willson. Published under exclusive licence by Emerald Publishing Limited


Half Title Page

Looking for Information

Series Title Page

Studies in Information

Recent Volumes

Fidelia Ibekwe

European Origins of Library and Information Science

Jack Andersen and Laura Skouvig

The Organization of Knowledge: Caught Between Global Structures and Local Meaning

Jack Andersen

Genre Theory in Information Studies

Dania Bilal and Jamshid Beheshti

New Directions in Children's and Adolescents' Information Behavior Research

Christine Bruce, Kate Davis, Hilary Hughes, Helen Partridge and Ian Stoodley

Information Experience: Approaches to Theory and Practice

Mark Hepworth and Geoff Walton

Developing People's Information Capabilities: Fostering Information Literacy in Educational, Workplace and Community Contexts

Jung-Ran Park and Lynne C. Howarth

New Directions in Information Organization

Amanda Spink and Jannica Heinström

Trends and Research: Europe

Gunilla Widén and Kim Holmberg

Social Information Research

Dirk Lewandowski

Web Search Engine Research

Donald O. Case and Lisa M. Given

Looking for Information, Fourth Edition

Amanda Spink and Diljit Singh

Trends and Research: Asia-Oceania

Amanda Spink and Jannica Heinstrom

New Directions in Information Behaviour

Eileen G. Abels and Deborah P. Klein

Business Information: Needs and Strategies

Leo Egghe

Power Laws in the Information Production Process: Lotkaian Informetrics

Mike Thelwall

Link Analysis: An Information Science Approach

Matthew Locke Saxton and John V. Richardson

Understanding Reference Transactions: Transforming Art Into a Science

Robert M. Hayes

Models for Library Management, Decision-Making, and Planning

Charles T. Meadow, Bert R. Boyce and Donald H. Kraft

Text Information Retrieval Systems, Second Edition

Title Page

Studies in Information

Looking for Information: Examining Research on How People Engage With Information

Fifth Edition

By

Lisa M. Given

RMIT University, Australia

Donald O. Case

University of Kentucky, USA

And

Rebekah Willson

McGill University, Canada

United Kingdom – North America – Japan – India – Malaysia – China

Copyright Page

Emerald Publishing Limited

Howard House, Wagon Lane, Bingley BD16 1WA, UK

Fifth edition 2023

Copyright © 2023 Lisa M. Given, Donald O. Case and Rebekah Willson.

Published under exclusive licence by Emerald Publishing Limited.

Reprints and permissions service

Contact:

No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without either the prior written permission of the publisher or a licence permitting restricted copying issued in the UK by The Copyright Licensing Agency and in the USA by The Copyright Clearance Center. Any opinions expressed in the chapters are those of the authors. Whilst Emerald makes every effort to ensure the quality and accuracy of its content, Emerald makes no representation implied or otherwise, as to the chapters' suitability and application and disclaims any warranties, express or implied, to their use.

British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data

A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library

ISBN: 978-1-80382-424-6 (Print)

ISBN: 978-1-80382-423-9 (Online)

ISBN: 978-1-80382-425-3 (Epub)

ISSN: 2055-5377 (Series)

List of Figures, Tables and Sidebars

Chapter 1 Information Behavior: An Introduction
Table 1.1. Key Concepts Referred to in Information Behavior Research.
Sidebar (Section 1.3) Must information be useful?
Sidebar (Section 1.3) Does information require intentions?
Sidebar (Section 1.3) Must information be true?
Sidebar (Section 1.4.1) Myth #1: Only “objective” information is valuable.
Sidebar (Section 1.4.1) Myth #2: More information is always better.
Table 1.2. The Evolution of Information Behavior Research Questions, From System-Oriented to Holistic Approaches.
Sidebar (Section 1.4.1) Myth #3: Objective information can be transmitted out of context.
Sidebar (Section 1.4.1) Myth #4: Only formal sources, such as scientific journals or vetted institutions, are essential.
Sidebar (Section 1.4.1) Myth #5: There is relevant information for every need.
Sidebar (Section 1.4.2) Myth #6: Every problem has a solution.
Sidebar (Section 1.4.2.1) Myth #7: It is always possible to make information available or accessible.
Sidebar (Section 1.4.2.1) Myth #8: Material information, such as books or websites, will satisfy people's needs.
Sidebar (Section 1.4.2.2) Myth #9: Individual situations and contexts can be ignored.
Sidebar (Section 1.4.2.3) Myth #10: People make easy, conflict-free connections between external information and their internal reality.
Table 1.3. Moving From Atomistic to Holistic Approaches in Studies of Information Behavior.
Chapter 2 The Evolution of Information Behavior Research
Sidebar (Section 2.3.1) Motivations for Information Seeking: Reducing Uncertainty
Sidebar (Section 2.3.3) Motivations for Information Seeking: Making Sense
Sidebar (Section 2.4) What Happened to Gatekeeping?
Fig. 2.1. A Timeline of Digital “Firsts” That Have Had a Significant Impact on People's Experiences With Information.
Chapter 3 The Complex Nature of Information Behavior
Sidebar (Section 3.1.3) Misinformation vs. Disinformation – What's the Difference?
Sidebar (Section 3.1.3) Misinformation and Disinformation: Examples of Information Behavior Studies
Sidebar (Section 3.2.1) The COVID-19 Pandemic as Context for People's Information Experiences
Sidebar (Section 3.2.1) Misinformation and Disinformation: A Particular Problem in the Pandemic
Sidebar (Section 3.2.4) Conspiracy Theories: Complex Examples of Disinformation
Sidebar (Section 3.2.6) The Rise of Fake News: A Major Research Focus
Chapter 4 Metatheories, Theories, and Models
Sidebar (Section 4.1.1) Epistemology
Sidebar (Section 4.1.2) Ontology
Sidebar (Section 4.1.3) Axiology
Sidebar (Section 4.2.2) Practice Theory
Sidebar (Section 4.3) Discursive Positioning
Table 4.1. Most-Cited Theorists and Formal Theories in Four Journals, 2002–2022.
Sidebar (Section 4.3.1) Social Network Theory
Sidebar (Section 4.5.1) Communities of Practice Theory
Table 4.2. Information Behavior Models Profiled in Earlier Editions of Looking for Information (Case, 2002, 2007, 2012; Case & Given, 2016).
Fig. 4.1. The Kuhlthau Model.
Fig. 4.2. The Savolainen and Thomson Model.
Fig. 4.3. The Robson and Robinson Model.
Fig. 4.4. The Meyer Model.
Fig. 4.5. The Wilson Model.
Chapter 5 Research Design, Methodologies, and Methods
Sidebar (Section 5.1.1) Common Sources of Human Error
Sidebar (Section 5.1.2) Methodology
Sidebar (Section 5.1.2) Methods
Table 5.1. Methodologies and Methods for Data Collection and Analysis.
Sidebar (Section 5.3.1) Online Questionnaires: A Mainstay for Gathering Descriptive Data in the Pandemic
Sidebar (Section 5.3.1.1) Qualitative Studies of COVID-19: An Emerging Research Focus
Sidebar (Section 5.3.3.1) Big Data and COVID-19: A Common Analytic Approach
Chapter 6 Reviewing, Critiquing, Concluding, and Futuring
Sidebar (Section 6.1) United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals
Fig. 6.1. Seven Global Megatrends.

About the Authors

Lisa M. Given, PhD, FASSA, is Director of the Social Change Enabling Impact Platform, and Professor of Information Sciences, RMIT University (Melbourne, Australia). Her interdisciplinary research in human information behavior brings a critical, social research lens to studies of technology use and user-focused design. Her studies embed social change, focusing on diverse settings and populations, and methodological innovations. A former President of the Association for Information Science and Technology (ASIS&T), and the Canadian Association for Information Science (CAIS), Lisa is a Fellow of the Academy of the Social Sciences in Australia and has served on the Australian Research Council's (ARC's) College of Experts. In 2021 she received the ASIS&T SIG-USE Award for Outstanding Contributions to Information Behavior Research and was named a Fellow of the SIG-USE Academy. She has received funding from the ARC, Canadian Institutes for Health Research, and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada, working with university and community partners across disciplines. She is Editor-in-Chief of ASIS&T's Annual Review of Information Science and Technology. She completed her MLIS (1996) and PhD (2001) at The University of Western Ontario (Canada). You can follow her on Twitter @lisagiven and Mastodon @lisagiven@mastodon.social and read about her work at http://lisagiven.com/.

Donald O. Case, PhD, is Professor Emeritus at the University of Kentucky (Lexington, USA), where he was Professor in the College of Communication and Information for 21 years, serving as Director of the School of Information Science for three years. After completing his MLS at Syracuse University (1977) and PhD at Stanford (1984), he was a faculty member at the University of California, Los Angeles. During 1989 he received a four-month Fulbright Fellowship to lecture at the Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Portugal, and in 2011 a one-month Fulbright award to lecture at three universities in Finland. Case's research interests include information behavior, health-related information, and information policy. He is the author of over 50 academic articles on these and other topics. He authored the first edition of this book, Looking for Information: A Survey of Research on Information Seeking, Needs, and Behavior (2002), which was awarded the Best Book of the Year Award by the Association for Information Science & Technology (ASIS&T). He was President of ASIS&T during 2008–2009 and has been a member of the Editorial Board of the Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology for 30 years.

Rebekah Willson, PhD, is Assistant Professor in the School of Information Studies, McGill University (Montreal, Canada). Her research focuses on information behavior and information practices, particularly with individuals and groups undergoing transitions and living with uncertainty, which has been funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. She has served as Chair of the Association for Information Science & Technology's (ASIS&T) Special Interest Group for Information Use, Seeking, and Needs (SIG-USE) and as guest editor of two special issues of the Journal of the Association of Information Science and Technology (JASIS&T) on information behavior (Special Issue on Information Behavior & Information Practices Theory and Retrospective Special Issue on Information Behavior). She is a member of the Editorial Board for JASIS&T and President of the Canadian Association for Information Science (2022–2023). She completed her MLIS at University of Alberta (Canada, 2008) and PhD at Charles Sturt University (Australia, 2016).

Preface

We are thrilled to introduce the fifth edition of Looking for Information – and with a revised subtitle: Examining Research on How People Engage with Information. This change in title reflects the overall broadening of focus across information behavior studies; just as the field has moved on from a primary focus on information seeking and needs to embrace concepts such as use, creation, and embodiment, so have we.

The book's first edition was published in 2002 and it was awarded the Best Information Science Book at that time by the Association for Information Science and Technology. New editions followed in 2007, 2012 and 2016, including translation of the fourth edition into Chinese and Greek. We are very proud of the large and loyal following we have gained, around the world, over these 20 years. For those of you reading this book for the first time – welcome! We are sure you will find some interesting insights within these pages and that you will be intrigued to learn more about the evolution of research on people's engagement with information. For returning readers – thank you! We have enjoyed discussing this book with you over the years and hope you enjoy the new approach we have taken with this new edition.

With this edition, we very purposely welcome readers from outside of information science who will benefit from reviewing key outcomes and trends in information behavior research. There is an increasing focus on interdisciplinarity as researchers (and society) grapple with the world's complex issues, including climate change, geopolitics, and adoption of new technologies. The COVID-19 pandemic provides a powerful case example in the need for health researchers to partner with experts in human information behavior, as misinformation and disinformation continue to shape global uptake of vaccinations and other public health interventions. There has never been a better, or more pressing, time for us to work together to address such complex questions in contemporary society.

The Book's Scope

Looking for Information provides an in-depth look at international research on people's engagement with information. It reviews a century of scholarship, providing examples of research approaches, models, and theories used in information behavior studies. The book is intended for researchers at all levels, from senior academics looking for an overview of key issues or theories, to graduate and undergraduate students who need an introduction to topics and approaches. The book is primarily focused on research conducted in the disciplinary home of information behavior research – information science. As information science is inherently interdisciplinary, the book also includes relevant citations from related fields, such as media and communication, sociology, psychology, digital humanities, education, business, management, medicine, nursing, and public health, among others. The studies cited in the book include a mix of quantitative, qualitative, and textual approaches used to investigate a wide variety of research problems.

Information behavior researchers have expanded their epistemological, methodological, and technological repertoires over the past 25 years. Since the previous (fourth) edition, the adoption of arts-based and mixed methods studies has continued, and with interdisciplinary projects expanding, globally. In this book, we present a detailed overview of the current state of information behavior research, including the new trends we see on the horizon. We cover the core topics explored in the discipline, including the populations, settings, contexts, and activities that researchers explore. We discuss key historic works alongside new innovations, providing readers with a solid overview of both landmark studies and cutting-edge trends. As with previous editions, we retain the book's core purpose – i.e., to outline the common and essential aspects of people's information behaviors by presenting robust examples of publications that demonstrate the contribution of this research area to information science and other disciplines.

A New Look and Feel

Readers familiar with the fourth edition of this book will note that the number of chapters is now reduced (to six) and the content is streamlined. The literature continues to grow at a fast pace, which makes the task of reviewing all new works published between editions that much more challenging! With this fifth edition, we include more than 1,200 publications, with the newest additions published in the last seven years (November 2015–2022). We removed at least 100 older references, replacing them with newer, contemporary examples. We also expanded our scope to include commentary on emergent areas (e.g., information creation) and those that received less attention, previously (e.g., information use).

Given the vast amount of literature published to date, we knew the book would either need to expand into two volumes or be refreshed as a single volume. We chose the latter, resulting in a significant remastering of the book's design. With this edition, we introduce new design features (such as sidebars and tables) that enable us to retain content within a smaller textual footprint. We carefully reviewed our use of appendices, tables, figures, and bulleted lists, to balance quick access to summaries and highlights, alongside long-form narratives. The result is a reformulated and streamlined approach to the layout of the book, while retaining the content and focus that our readers expect.

We constructed each chapter to serve as a stand-alone piece of writing, to make it easier to include select chapters on course syllabi, and to facilitate downloading of chapters on e-readers. Each chapter now has its own, complete reference list, as well as Our Top 3 Must Read Recommendations. We retained the full reference list to collate references from the entire book, and we have also retained detailed author and subject indices. We have also added DOIs to citations, where these were available. As a result of the streamlined chapter structure, we no longer group the chapters; however, we do retain a detailed table of contents for the chapters. All these features support findability of key concepts and cited authors, and we hope these will enhance your reading experience.

Our Approach to Citing Examples and Relevant Literature

As with previous editions, we portray both the depth and breadth of the information behavior literature by presenting selected studies that illustrate key topics. Choosing which studies to highlight for this volume has been challenging, and we have employed a few different approaches to make our selections. First, we retained the previous framework, which gathered studies by roles and occupations as part of our detailed overview of historic approaches to information behavior research. We then extended this framework to examine more holistic approaches to research, which account for situations and contexts that shape people's experiences. We have exercised judgment in choosing studies that we see as unique, well done or illustrative of a particular population or approach. We have also highlighted studies using innovative methodological or theoretical approaches, or those that reflect the ongoing shift towards interdisciplinarity.

Second, we omitted investigations focused exclusively on information retrieval and people's searching practices from channels, sources, or systems. Most of these excluded studies concern the use of the internet, social media, online databases, and library catalogs, and together these constitute a huge literature. The focus of these excluded works is on the system or source, rather than the person who is searching; for this reason, they fall outside the boundaries of our review.

Third, we focus primarily on recent publications, especially those from 2000 to 2022. In some cases, older items are portrayed to highlight the shifts in assumptions, methods, and findings that have taken place over several decades. We also cite earlier, landmark discussions and definitions of core concepts, to ensure proper credit and to provide a historical perspective. By focusing on works from recent decades, we aim to provide an efficient means for reviewing developments in the field, while keeping the book to a manageable size.

How to Read This Book

Chapter 1 Information Behavior: An Introduction provides an overview of foundational concepts and key terms and definitions, including information behavior, information practice, information experience, seeking, sharing, needs, use, creation, and encountering, among others. The nature of information is also explored, including such topics as truth and intentionality in the information people seek, as well as common myths related to information use. The chapter examines the scope of information behavior research, including its focus on people's holistic and complex relationships with information.

Chapter 2 The Evolution of Information Behavior Research presents a brief, historical overview of information behavior research. The chapter discusses the traditional research focus on people's roles (e.g., academics; managers) and activities (e.g., seeking), as well as issues related to motivation and gatekeeping practices. This chapter introduces the history of information behavior research, expanding on the concepts introduced in Chapter 1, and setting the stage to explore contemporary, holistic studies in Chapter 3.

Chapter 3 The Complex Nature of Information Behavior examines contemporary approaches to information behavior research, focusing primarily on people's holistic experiences of information. This includes the shift towards approaches that embrace socio-cultural contexts, affect, and embodiment, among other topics. Misinformation and disinformation are explored in depth, and the chapter also provides a detailed snapshot of research on COVID-19.

Chapter 4 Metatheories, Theories, and Models examines the paradigmatic and theoretical influences that have shaped information behavior research, alongside detailed discussions of methodologies and methods. This chapter mentions the approaches used in empirical studies, but also explores conceptual and philosophical publications that address the critical concepts shaping information behavior, overall.

Chapter 5 Research Design, Methodologies, and Methods discusses how information behavior researchers have designed their studies, collected and analyzed data, and written about their findings, over time. This chapter maps the evolution from primarily descriptive, quantitative studies, through the adoption of qualitative and mixed methods approaches, to the use of arts-based and creative designs. The chapter also highlights the increasing shift towards the societal impact of research, globally.

Chapter 6 Reviewing, Critiquing, Concluding, and Futuring highlights critical reviews of information behavior research and explores emerging trends. The chapter examines global megatrends (e.g., climate change, sustainable development) and what the future may hold for information behavior scholars.

Acknowledgements

Over the last 20 years, countless individuals have provided advice, ideas and reflections on what to include in Looking for Information. We are grateful for the many people who have engaged with this book over the years, including those who have added it on course reading lists. We thank you for your ongoing support! This fifth edition has benefited greatly from the help of Dr Linus Tan, who assisted with graphics and referencing. Thanks also to the editors at Emerald, for their continued guidance and support.

Lisa M. Given

Donald O. Case

Rebekah Willson